My birthday is on August 21!
Picture from a birthday party in 2016. |
There are two topics for my Long Shadow post. The first involves abortion (trigger warning). The second is just a collection of happy pictures from a place where a shadow matters once a year.
Long Shadow |
(564-word essay)
Crime rates rise and fall from many factors, some that take decades to reveal themselves. There are ways to impact the crime rate immediately, such as altering laws, improving crime prevention measures, and giving law enforcement better training and resources. It has been postulated that permitting abortion and expanding birth control have a long-term impact on crime rates.
The reason behind it is that children who are wanted by someone with the means to properly care for them are less likely to fall into a life of crime. (The study may have focused on "blue-collar crimes" instead of "white-collar crimes.") Most notably, the odds of becoming a prostitute, drug dealer, or burglar decrease.
The idea is that someone who is prepared for the responsibility of parenthood is more likely to provide a good education, proper nutrition, a stable home, and the mental and emotional love a child requires. An excellent book to read on this topic is Freakonomics.
Some people are willing to trade a higher rate if it means abortions and birth control are more difficult to access. A fair amount of those people also do not view rape, child molestation, pedophilia, or sexual slavery as crimes. There are even some who wish to make human trafficking legal, particularly in regard to the sale of female children. Rather than as fellow humans, females are often seen as objects to them.
This type of thought may explain why so many "pro-life" protesters in America march outside of free or low-cost obstetrician clinics, intimidating women who are seeking pregnancy care as well as those considering abortions. The same protesters are less likely to stand outside of upper-class locations with obstetrics residency training, which is where the medical procedure is generally learned. Training tends to include the procedure because not all pregnancies are viable, and sometimes can result in the imminent death of both the mother and baby. However, some people strongly believe that life begins when cells can mimic a beat, but a woman of childbearing years should die if her pregnancy goes poorly, even when medicine makes that death avoidable.
Death as a predestined outcome. This means that, perhaps, some unwanted babies need to be born to grow up to become killers, sexual-assaulters, robbers, gang leaders, drug dealers, etc. Perhaps Americans need a certain amount of crime so that there are "bad guys" and thus the possibility of "good guys"?
Legal arguments as to which medical procedures a qualified medical professional should have the option of offering to a patient could be based on how it impacts society as a whole. Do religious morals have the same impact for people who do not believe in them? Should the religions and cultures of others be imposed upon people who do not share them? Where do laws come from, and do any exist for non-religious reasons?
If a law allowing abortion and expanded birth control were firmly in place, no longer teetering on the edge, would it cast a long shadow of reducing crime? If so, is that worth having some people sacrifice their moral or religious beliefs that what someone else does impacts their own afterlife? If science could remove a fetus in the first trimester and grow it to term, would that be better? Would that help or hurt the hundreds of thousands of children in the US who are waiting to be adopted?
You want to talk about a LONG SHADOW?
Punxsutawney Phil is a groundhog in Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania. I was in Punxsutawney a few years ago. (Not on Groundhog day. Sorry.) Here are a few pictures from the town where, for one day a year, a rodent's shadow is newsworthy.
"According to the tradition, if Phil sees his shadow and returns to his hole, he has predicted six more weeks of winter-like weather." ⛄❄
Tourist Phil |
Tourist stuff in town. |
Me with Liberty Phil |
Me with a hand-carved Phil statue |
Dentist Phil |
Happy Birthday for tomorrow (our time), and probably the day after your time.
ReplyDeleteAnd a big yes to safe contraception and abortion being available, for those who want or need them.
Much like euthanasia (which I also support) their availability does not make them compulsory.
Their absence casts very long shadows indeed.
Thank you.
DeleteWish you a very happy birthday.
ReplyDeleteProbably birthday ensued the topic of birth. (just joking). Relevant and contemporary issue. It seems like lawyers field day is around. If laws are framed for aborting pregnancies due to rape, then courts could be overwhelmed with lawsuits for determining which pregnancy is from rape and which one is not. Then there would be technologies to determine the matter. And so on.
Birth control cannot be mandatory in democratic societies even for adolescent, unemployed, poorly employed or anyone for that would be biologically oppressive. Only light is that the matter can still be discussed peacefully.
And overwhelmed courts do not act "first trimester" fast. π Though I would also like to live in a world where rape was treated more like a horrifying crime 100% of the time, and rapist as people to be shunned. But that world would be devastating to the porn industry. πΆ
DeleteHappy birthday tomorrow!
ReplyDeleteWomen everywhere need safe and affordable access to all types of healthcare - including contraceptive care and abortions
π₯ Here here!
DeleteHappy birthday Jamie!
ReplyDeleteYou've indeed written a sobering take on abortion and its availability and aftermath. It is true that the clinics chosen for demonstrations are the free, low socio-economic ones. Just another example of an unbalanced society.
Wow. How does anyone spell Punxsutawney? What a mouthful! Or eyeful! Thanks for the pics!
Funny story
DeleteI have OnStar navigation. When we decided to to pit stop here, I pressed the button to ask for directions. The poor representative asked, "ummm... can you spell that?" My brother, without missing a beat, spelled it correctly. The representative and I were equally impressed.
Happy birthday! You've brought out a very relevant issue in your piece, something the world has been pondering upon for a long time now.
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately true. I'd like science to present another option for people to fight over, one where a fetus could easily (with no possible harm to the original host) be transplanted to the father or something. Give the woman a way out of the equation.
DeleteHappy birthday! I liked both parts of your entry - one serious and topical, the other lighthearted, though I have no idea how to pronounce the place name.
ReplyDeleteMy own view is that in any civilised, just society a woman should be able to do what she damn well likes with her own body and its capability to reproduce. The state should not be interfering in her rights.
https://youtu.be/GncQtURdcE4
Delete16 seconds in.
Happy Birthday, it's my mom's birthday too!
ReplyDeletePux-a-tany is a silly celebration but it cuts up winter and that's a great thing up north.
The argument of abortion is just as silly as a groundhog predicting spring.
π That's close, and how people without a Pennsylvania accent say it. (Which, to be fair, most Pennsylvanians don't have the accent.) Tany is more tawny. Instead of pulling your lips back like a smile, you push them forward like duck-face.
DeleteHappy birthday to your mom.
π The groundhog (or his handlers) know more about weather than most politicians know about female anatomy. That's saying something with only a 39% accuracy rate. π€£π€£π€£ππππ€£π€£π€£π€£
Happy birthday, Jamie.
ReplyDeleteYour #prochoice essay is amazing. I'm definitely with you on this issue. I never thought about the connection of abortion laws to crime rates, but I'm a firm believer that unwanted children make everyone in the family miserable. Of course, birth control is even better, less invasive, but whatever the way, a woman should be able to control her own body. The postulate that she must relinquish that control to anyone else - her husband or a bunch of religious fanatics or some collection of cells growing in her uterus - is absurd.
The groundhog pictures are wonderful. Made me smile.
Thanks.
DeleteAnd I'm glad I gave you a smile.
It's a very complex issue and many people only see it in black and white rather than examining the gray areas and trying to come up with solutions that are better for all. Personally, I believe that abortion must remain a safe and legal medical procedure regardless of how I may feel about it personally.
ReplyDeleteThe "sex work is work" types really get under my skin. No, sex work is not "just work." There is no other job where workers are expected to have sex with people that they really don't want to be having sex with. I watched a documentary about human trafficking. One of the prostitutes said that she has one foot in the grave every time she agrees to let a punter be with her because she doesn't know which of them may be the one to attack and possibly kill her.
Yeah. That's another very complicated issue.
DeleteHi,
ReplyDeleteHappy Birthday!
Your submission made me think. Having known a few women that have suffered emotionally and mentally after an abortion, I ponder deeply over the rights of the fetus that is no more.
Shalom aleichem,
Pat Garcia
I'd like to see far more laws, and enforcement of them, to prevent what causes many abortions to happen. Obviously not the cases where it's because the fetus is suffering or life is in danger. But the others.
DeleteThere is a lot in this piece to consider. For me it comes down to societal standards. If women were treated as human beings, instead of baby incubators or sexual appliances, I don't think there would even be a debate about birth control or abortion. In the world we live in, a man can choose to be or not to be a father, but a woman can't always choose to carry or not to carry a child in her body. Unless more men start living with the fear of being raped and start being forced to raise every child they conceive, they will never care about how women's minds and bodies are treated. As long as we live in a world where a man won't pay a mother (trying to feed her children) to clean his house but will pay her to take off her clothes, this will always be an issue. Whether religion plays a role in the debate or not, the big question is "Do woman have control of their lives: economically, physically, and emotionally?" Not even going to touch fetuses right now.
ReplyDeleteVery true. Have you read the book? I only hit a few highlights because this prompt made me think about this.
DeleteI haven't but have been intrigued by it. Think my husband watched a documentary based on it.
DeleteI hope you had a great birthday!
ReplyDeleteThis is an important topic. Access to contraceptives and abortion do indeed lead to a drop in blue collar crime. I like that you differentiated between blue and white collar crime here, by the way. When people talk about crime rates, they never seem to consider the white collar ones, only the crimes committed by the poor.
I also liked your point that demonstrators tend to target free or low cost clinics. A lot of people want them shut down completely without considering what that would do for women who are going for pregnancy care or cancer screenings.
You left us with so much to think about. Thank you.
A few years ago I took a friend for her medical appointment at a clinic. Not pregnant. Not for contraception.
DeleteDidn't stop the protesters from being very ugly toward us.
Her job didn't have health care. Without the medical care, she would become seriously ill.
They didn't care about that, about her life.
A belated happy birthday.
ReplyDeletePS: Never thought that even groundhogs became celebrities.
Thank you!
DeleteAnd only in Pennsylvania. Ha ha.
My own thoughts and beliefs aside, you've written a very interesting article.
ReplyDeleteThank you.
DeleteBelated Happy birthday! An interesting take on the prompt, and one you've taken a lot of effort over. Fasicnating stuff. Well done!
ReplyDeleteThanks.
DeleteHi Jamie - yes belated happy birthday - but here's to a year of happy celebrations. Love the photo - and I'm just glad I live here and we have choice. I read the Freakanomics book a while back ... it's interesting. Take care and all the best - Hilary
ReplyDeleteThanks.
DeleteI've never needed the choice, but I feel there's a lot about the topic that is overlooked. This being just one part.
Even before you mentioned it, I was thinking about that chapter in Freakonomics. It's an interesting and provocative hypothesis. As for me, no doubt that abortion should be legal and available.
ReplyDeleteAlso... happy Belated Birthday!
Thanks. Glad we've read the same book.
DeleteThought-provoking post, offering some insights into the dark reasons some want to make abortion and contraception illegal or difficult to get. And the contrast with the goofiness of Groundhog Day made me smile. Happy (late) birthday!
ReplyDelete